
“Not Not Normal” by Peter E. Fenton
Reviewed by Jeff Baker
Peter E. Fenton’s YA novel “Not Not Normal” features relationships, bullying, loss and self-doubt with realistically drawn characters and situations. Oh yeah, and books.
Lots of books.
“Not Not Normal,” is a “Hi/Lo,” a “high interest, low reading complexity book” meant for young readers who do not have a high reading level for one reason or another. Publisher Lorimer has featured a good many of these under their “Real Love” imprint.
Jordan Shepherd is starting his Junior Year of High School. He is devoted to order and sameness and loathes change but he’s planning on making a big change (for him) namely re-naming the school book club he runs. In his corner are people like his widowed Veterinarian Dad and Emma, a friend from school who admits she’d consider dating him “if you didn’t prefer boys.”
Jordan’s Dad is still recovering from the death from Cancer of his wife and Jordan’s Mom several years before. This drove Jordan to become more obsessed with routine and order and it caused his Dad to relocate from their old house and its memories. Different school and different life for Jordan.
Jordan’s refuge is books, especially his late Mom’s science-fiction books, which he has shelved in an orderly fashion in his room in the apartment he shares with his Dad. Not only is Jordan a reader but the books make him feel closer to his late Mom.
Fenton handle’s Jordan’s situation, especially his panic attacks perfectly. The fact that all this was intensified with the loss of his Mom as well as Jordan’s routine to stave off the attacks: identifying four things he can smell, touch and see, are well-done touches.
Into Jordan’s well-ordered bubble busts uninhibited, openly Gay Nathan on Sign-Up Day for school clubs when everything seems to suddenly be going wrong. Nathan stands up for Jordan against the school bully and they don’t become fast friends immediately. Their relationship takes some realistic twists and turns as they learn about each other and learn to support each other. Nathan giving Jordan a much-needed push to do a school presentation and Jordan giving Nathan an ear to bend about his own rough home situation which Nathan’s bravado masks.
Both young men each give the other a shoulder to cry on and they could use it. While this is a romance, it does not come off as contrived.
And it all ties in to Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night.”
Adding to the story are the well-defined moments at Playter Heights High School; not just faculty, staff and students but the routine of life in 2024 (when the book came out) including teachers referencing the recent events of COVID while talking about the plague of Shakespeare’s day.
“Not Not Normal” is another fine addition to the catalog of YA books in this Lorimer series and to Fenton’s own body of work.
It should be noted that a “Shepherd” is one who guides and herds others. In other words, someone who works to maintain order.
—end—
NOTE: A version of this review was posted to “Goodreads” and “Amazon.”









